NJ.com Reports 20% More Homes For Sale in NJ
The number of homes for sale in New Jersey has increased by 20% compared with a year earlier. There were 17,519 homes for sale in September 2025 and 20,996 in September 2026, according to data from the Otteau Group.
“This is certainly a step in the right direction,” said Jeffrey Otteau, founder and chief economist at the Otteau Group. “But … we’re still only about halfway to where we need to be for the housing market to normalize.”
A normal market would have 40,000 homes listed for sale — nearly double what there are now. The last time there were nearly 40,000 homes for sale was 2019, according to data from the Otteau Group.
“For the inventory of houses to rebound and get to a 40,000 level, we’re going to need to see interest rates get into the mid to low 5% range,” Otteau said. Rates dipped to 6% in February 2026 but have jumped to 7.3% as of October. Rates won’t get into the mid- to low-5% range for “probably another year,” Otteau said. Michael Read, principal of Bridgeway Mortgage & Real Estate Services in Morristown, says there could be one advantage for buyers in the current market — less competition.
Less competition could keep prices lower than would result from large bidding wars. And Read argues that a lower price at a higher interest rate could be good math.